Post by @Our_DA
89% credible (95% factual, 77% presentation). The content accurately reflects the DA's October 2025 proposal to replace BEE with the Economic Inclusion for All Bill, focusing on poverty-targeted incentives. However, the presentation exhibits partisan bias through omission framing, neglecting BEE's successes in increasing black ownership in certain sectors and its historical context as a response to apartheid.
Analysis Summary
The Democratic Alliance (DA) is promoting its Economic Inclusion for All Bill as a replacement for Black Economic Empowerment (BEE), emphasizing job creation, poverty reduction, and skills development through a transparent public procurement system. This proposal aligns with recent DA announcements and critiques of BEE's effectiveness, though it faces opposition from the ANC. The accompanying infographic contrasts BEE's alleged failures with the bill's promised benefits, highlighting partisan framing.
Original Content
The Facts
The content accurately reflects the DA's recent policy proposal to amend public procurement laws by replacing race-based BEE with poverty-targeted incentives, supported by official DA statements and media reports from October 2025. However, claims of BEE's total failure are partisan and omit evidence of BEE's successes in increasing black ownership in some sectors. Mostly Accurate with Partisan Bias.
Benefit of the Doubt
The post advances the DA's liberal economic agenda by positioning their bill as a superior, inclusive alternative to ANC's BEE, emphasizing transparency, job outcomes, and broad empowerment to appeal to voters frustrated with unemployment and corruption. It selectively highlights BEE's downsides like cadre enrichment and job losses while omitting counter-arguments such as BEE's role in addressing apartheid legacies and potential risks of the DA's model exacerbating inequalities without race considerations. This framing shapes perception by portraying the DA as pragmatic reformers versus the ANC as outdated and corrupt, potentially polarizing discourse on economic policy.
Visual Content Analysis
Images included in the original content
VISUAL DESCRIPTION
A promotional infographic divided into two columns: the left side features a photo of a man in a suit (likely Cyril Ramaphosa) with yellow-highlighted text criticizing ANC's BEE as race-based, enriching elites, encouraging corruption, complex, and causing job losses and stagnant growth; the right side shows a photo of a man embracing an elderly woman, with blue-highlighted text praising the DA's Economic Inclusion for All Bill for focusing on poverty alleviation, job creation, transparency, simplicity, and driving investment and skills for all South Africans. The DA logo and South African flag colors are prominent at the top and bottom.
TEXT IN IMAGE
DA's Economic Inclusion for All Bill ANC's failed BEE Based on race and political connections Enriches the politically connected few Encourages fronting and corruption Complex, costly, and confusing Jobs for pals Focused on race R1 trillion to fewer than 100 people Stagnant growth, rising unemployment DA's Economic Inclusion for All Bill Focused on lifting people out of poverty, creating jobs and driving real impact Empowers all South Africans through opportunity Promotes transparency and fair competition Simple and accessible Jobs for all Focused on outcomes Empowerment for Africans millions Will drive investment, develop skills, and open equal opportunities for all
MANIPULATION
No signs of editing, inconsistencies, or artifacts; the image appears to be a standard digital graphic created for promotional purposes without alterations to photos or text.
TEMPORAL ACCURACY
The infographic references the DA's newly proposed bill from October 2025, matching the post's context and recent news coverage, with no outdated elements visible.
LOCATION ACCURACY
The image does not specify or depict a particular location; it focuses on policy comparison without geographical clues.
FACT-CHECK
The infographic's claims about BEE's failures (e.g., R1 trillion to few people, corruption) are based on DA critiques and some economic reports but are exaggerated; BEE has increased black ownership from 0% to 34% in JSE-listed companies per 2023 data. The DA bill description aligns with official proposals to target poverty over race, as per DA's October 2025 launch, though implementation details remain untested.
How Is This Framed?
Biases, omissions, and misleading presentation techniques detected
The content omits the historical context of BEE as a response to apartheid legacies, presenting the DA bill as a straightforward superior alternative without explaining why BEE was implemented.
Problematic phrases:
"promotes real empowerment""new public procurement system"What's actually there:
BEE has increased black ownership in sectors like mining and finance per government reports
What's implied:
BEE provides no real empowerment
Impact: Leads readers to view BEE as wholly inadequate, polarizing views on economic policy and underestimating the complexity of redress measures.
Fails to report evidence of BEE's successes, such as increased black economic participation, while emphasizing its alleged failures like cadre enrichment.
Problematic phrases:
"delivers jobs, reduces poverty, and builds skills"What's actually there:
BEE contributed to 30% black ownership in JSE-listed companies by 2023 per B-BBEE Commission
What's implied:
BEE causes poverty and job losses without benefits
Impact: Misleads on the scale of BEE's impact, exaggerating its negatives to make the DA bill appear as the only solution.
Presents the DA bill's benefits in isolation, without discussing potential criticisms like risks of ignoring race in empowerment leading to persistent inequalities.
Problematic phrases:
"The DA's Economic Inclusion Bill promotes real empowerment"What's actually there:
Opposition from ANC highlights DA bill's potential to overlook racial disparities
What's implied:
Bill universally benefits all without drawbacks
Impact: Shapes perception of the DA as innovative reformers versus ANC as obstructive, fostering partisan division.
Cherry-picks promised outcomes of the bill (jobs, poverty reduction) while neglecting the broader economic challenges in South Africa that affect implementation.
Problematic phrases:
"delivers jobs, reduces poverty, and builds skills"What's actually there:
Unemployment at 32% in 2023 per Stats SA, with procurement reforms facing implementation hurdles
What's implied:
Bill will directly and immediately achieve these outcomes
Impact: Inflates perceived effectiveness of the bill, downplaying systemic barriers to success.
Sources & References
External sources consulted for this analysis
https://www.polity.org.za/article/da-proposes-bill-to-replace-bee-wants-ancs-support-2025-10-20
https://www.da.org.za/2023/11/da-rejects-public-procurement-bill
https://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/38294/
https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/002/2023/195/article-A002-en.xml
https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/202510/53515gen3559.pdf
https://www.treasury.gov.za/legislation/draft_bills/Public%20Procurement%20Bill%20for%20public%20comment%2019%20Feb%202020.pdf
https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/202312/b18b2023publicprocurement.pdf
https://www.citizen.co.za/news/opinion/da-can-expect-a-fight-with-new-bill/
https://georgeherald.com/News/Article/Politics/this-is-not-a-case-of-trying-to-repeat-apartheid-da-offers-the-anc-an-alternative-to-bbbeee-202510200317
https://polity.org.za/article/da-proposes-bill-to-replace-bee-wants-ancs-support-2025-10-20
https://ewn.co.za/2025/10/20/da-proposes-replacing-b-bbee-with-new-procurement-bill-focused-on-value-and-inclusion
https://taungdailynews.com/2025/10/20/da-calls-on-the-anc-to-put-people-before-cadres/
https://sabcnews.com/sabcnews/da-calls-for-scrapping-of-bee-blames-it-for-job-losses-cronyism
https://news24.com/politics/da-takes-aim-at-bee-with-bold-new-bill-focusing-on-poverty-not-race-20251020-0764
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1804799332211741153
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1739541557865259205
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1657717416367890436
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1666798977734328322
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1684823605702537216
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1653751309835677699
https://taungdailynews.com/2025/10/20/da-calls-on-the-anc-to-put-people-before-cadres/
https://www.polity.org.za/article/da-proposes-bill-to-replace-bee-wants-ancs-support-2025-10-20
https://taungdailynews.com/tag/with-an-inclusive-procurement-regime/
https://www.ewn.co.za/2025/10/20/da-proposes-replacing-b-bbee-with-new-procurement-bill-focused-on-value-and-inclusion
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-10-20/south-africa-s-da-proposes-bill-to-end-race-based-procurement
https://www.treasury.gov.za/comm_media/press/2025/2025060501%20OECD%20Economic%20Surveys%20of%20South%20Africa%202025.pdf
https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-economic-surveys-south-africa-2025_7e6a132a-en/full-report/enhancing-job-creation-and-workforce-integration-in-a-changing-economy_e1449aca.html
https://citizen.co.za/news/opinion/da-can-expect-a-fight-with-new-bill
https://georgeherald.com/News/Article/Politics/this-is-not-a-case-of-trying-to-repeat-apartheid-da-offers-the-anc-an-alternative-to-bbbeee-202510200317
https://taungdailynews.com/2025/10/20/da-calls-on-the-anc-to-put-people-before-cadres/
https://www.polity.org.za/article/da-proposes-bill-to-replace-bee-wants-ancs-support-2025-10-20
https://news24.com/politics/da-takes-aim-at-bee-with-bold-new-bill-focusing-on-poverty-not-race-20251020-0764
https://www.ewn.co.za/2025/10/20/da-proposes-replacing-b-bbee-with-new-procurement-bill-focused-on-value-and-inclusion
https://sowetan.co.za/news/2025-10-20-da-proposes-an-economic-inclusion-bill-to-oust-bee
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1804799332211741153
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1739541557865259205
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1792450016285462576
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/850343837411270657
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1666798977734328322
https://x.com/Our_DA/status/1919421995457859862
Want to see @Our_DA's track record?
View their credibility score and all analyzed statements