Post by @MatJGeorge
56% credible (60% factual, 45% presentation). The post accurately reports DA-era water tanker expenditure of R419 million but omits the total R777 million spent in the 2024/25 fiscal year under the new administration, engaging in cherry-picking and omission framing. While the factual claims are partially supported by financial records, the presentation lacks broader fiscal context and ongoing investigations, leading to a misleading narrative.
Analysis Summary
The post claims that official financial records reveal the previous DA administration under Cilliers Brink spent R419 million on water tankers, R80 million more than the current administration's R342 million since October 2024, while leaving R179 million in unpaid invoices. This counters DA and News24 allegations of R777 million overspending under the new ANC-led coalition by highlighting inherited debts and doubled water outages due to DA-era infrastructure neglect. However, broader context from recent reports indicates ongoing debates, with DA launching probes into total spending exceeding budgets amid rising water losses.
Original Content
The Facts
The post presents partisan claims supported by selective financial data aligning with ActionSA narratives, but independent reports confirm high overall tanker spending (R777 million total for 2024/25) under the new administration exceeding budgets, with DA-era issues acknowledged yet not fully debunking the overspend allegations. Partially accurate but misleading due to omission of total fiscal context and ongoing investigations.
Benefit of the Doubt
The author advances a pro-current administration (ANC-led coalition with ActionSA elements) agenda by framing the DA as fiscally irresponsible and the new government as diligent reformers, emphasizing reduced direct spending and inherited debts to deflect blame. Key omissions include the aggregate R777 million expenditure under the new regime—far above prior years—and failure to address persistent water infrastructure crises or DA probes into unauthorized spending, which shapes perception as a defensive counter-narrative rather than balanced accountability. This selective presentation portrays the DA's claims as 'fake news' while bolstering the author's political allies, potentially misleading readers on the full scale of municipal financial mismanagement.
Predictions Made
Claims about future events that can be verified later
Let’s see if News24 will correct the record and give South Africans the truth
Prior: 35% (predictions on media behavior uncertain). Evidence: Bias against News24. Posterior: 30%.
How Is This Framed?
Biases, omissions, and misleading presentation techniques detected
Omits the total R777 million expenditure for the 2024/25 fiscal year under the new administration, which includes the inherited debts, leading readers to believe the new government spent far less overall.
Problematic phrases:
"R342 million which is nearly R80 million less than what was spent under the DA""debunk this and expose"What's actually there:
R777 million total for 2024/25 including debts
What's implied:
New admin spent only R342 million total
Impact: Misleads readers into underestimating the scale of current spending and overattributing fiscal issues to the DA, altering perceptions of accountability.
Compares short-term new administration spending (since October 2024) to longer DA periods (e.g., full years), creating a misleading impression of efficiency without normalizing for time or total budget.
Problematic phrases:
"Since 16 October 2024, under the current administration, total verified expenditure... R342 million""Under the DA, Cilliers Brink spent over R419 million"What's actually there:
Partial year vs multi-year comparison
What's implied:
Direct apples-to-apples savings
Impact: Distorts scope, making the new administration appear more frugal than a full fiscal comparison would show, influencing judgments on fiscal responsibility.
Implies DA's infrastructure neglect directly caused doubled water outages without evidence linking specific underinvestment to the increase, attributing outcomes solely to prior administration.
Problematic phrases:
"the complete collapse of investment in water infrastructure under successive DA administrations that the new Mayor and her team are working hard to fix""this DOUBLED to 14 998"What's actually there:
Outages increased, but causation from investment collapse unproven amid broader factors like climate or maintenance
What's implied:
Direct DA fault for all rises
Impact: Creates false cause-effect, biasing readers to blame DA exclusively and credit new team prematurely for fixes.
Uses 'BREAKING' for financial records that likely predate the post, presenting ongoing political debates as sudden revelations to heighten attention.
Problematic phrases:
"BREAKING: Official Tshwane Financial Records Reveal"What's actually there:
What's implied:
Impact: Amplifies perceived novelty and importance, prompting quicker acceptance of the partisan narrative over deliberate verification.
Fails to mention DA-initiated probes into new administration's unauthorized spending and exceeding budgets, despite high-level context confirming ongoing investigations into total overspend.
Problematic phrases:
"the DA wants to hide""Let’s see if News24 will correct the record"What's actually there:
Investigations into R777m total and water losses
What's implied:
No such counter-claims or issues exist
Impact: Withholds evidence of mutual accountability, framing the post as definitive truth and opponents as purely deceptive, deeply skewing reader trust.
Sources & References
External sources consulted for this analysis
https://pondolandtimes.co.za/actionsa-exposes-das-r777m-water-tanker-myth/
https://dagauteng.org.za/2025/10/da-launches-investigation-into-r777-million-tshwane-water-tanker-jackpot
https://www.citizen.co.za/news/tshwanes-r777m-water-tanker-scandal-sparks-fury/
https://centralnews.co.za/tshwane-eff-mmc-obakeng-responds-to-r777-million-water-tanker-overspend-awaits-full-finance-report-amid-da-probe/
https://iol.co.za/news/2025-10-21-mkp-plans-major-protest-over-tshwanes-r777-million-water-tanker-spending/
https://www.biznews.com/leadership/da-launches-investigation-tshwane-water-tankers
https://www.news24.com/investigations/tanking-finances-tshwanes-water-tanker-spend-spirals-to-r777m-under-anc-led-coalition-20251018-1068
https://citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/local-news/fury-as-tshwane-blows-r777m-on-tankers
https://iol.co.za/news/2025-10-21-mkp-plans-major-protest-over-tshwanes-r777-million-water-tanker-spending/
https://www.news24.com/investigations/tanking-finances-tshwanes-water-tanker-spend-spirals-to-r777m-under-anc-led-coalition-20251018-1068
https://newsday.co.za/south-africa/7855/r777-million-water-tanker-spend-sparks-tensions-in-tshwane-coalition/
https://www.biznews.com/leadership/da-launches-investigation-tshwane-water-tankers
https://centralnews.co.za/tshwane-eff-mmc-obakeng-responds-to-r777-million-water-tanker-overspend-awaits-full-finance-report-amid-da-probe/
https://www.citizen.co.za/news/tshwanes-r777m-water-tanker-scandal-sparks-fury/
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1836454497662501206
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1968360375868703150
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1968361932538396974
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1836708063300010191
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1895452956440576050
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1841420686033633471
https://www.news24.com/investigations/tanking-finances-tshwanes-water-tanker-spend-spirals-to-r777m-under-anc-led-coalition-20251018-1068
https://www.biznews.com/interviews/2024/12/03/coalition-chaos-cilliers-brink-tshwane
https://www.biznews.com/interviews/2024/11/01/brink-actionsa-anc-eff-tshwane
https://www.biznews.com/leadership/da-launches-investigation-tshwane-water-tankers
https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2025-10-20-da-wants-answers-about-tshwanes-r700m-water-tanker-bill/
https://pondolandtimes.co.za/actionsa-exposes-das-r777m-water-tanker-myth/
https://newsday.co.za/south-africa/7855/r777-million-water-tanker-spend-sparks-tensions-in-tshwane-coalition/
https://citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/local-news/fury-as-tshwane-blows-r777m-on-tankers
https://iol.co.za/news/2025-10-21-mkp-plans-major-protest-over-tshwanes-r777-million-water-tanker-spending
https://news24.com/investigations/tanking-finances-tshwanes-water-tanker-spend-spirals-to-r777m-under-anc-led-coalition-20251018-1068
https://biznews.com/leadership/da-launches-investigation-tshwane-water-tankers
https://centralnews.co.za/tshwane-eff-mmc-obakeng-responds-to-r777-million-water-tanker-overspend-awaits-full-finance-report-amid-da-probe
https://citizen.co.za/news/tshwanes-r777m-water-tanker-scandal-sparks-fury
https://ewn.co.za/2025/10/21/soil-of-sa-urges-tshwane-to-invest-money-in-permanent-water-infrastructure-instead-of-tankers
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1836454497662501206
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1968360375868703150
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1968361932538396974
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1836708063300010191
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1895452956440576050
https://x.com/MatJGeorge/status/1841420686033633471
Want to see @MatJGeorge's track record?
View their credibility score and all analyzed statements