Post by @jupliets
84% credible (88% factual, 73% presentation). The core claim about the poor code quality in the Coretax project by LG CNS-Qualysoft, as stated by Finance Minister Purbaya in October 2025, is factually supported. However, the presentation is marred by sensationalism and omission of government responses, such as hiring local experts to address the issue.
Analysis Summary
Finance Minister Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa revealed that the Rp1.2 trillion Coretax project, handled by LG CNS-Qualysoft consortium, involved programmers with skills equivalent to high school graduates, suggesting Indonesia was misled by foreign partners. This statement aligns with recent reports but is sensationalized for impact, omitting ongoing government fixes using local experts. The controversy highlights concerns over project quality and foreign involvement in national IT systems.
Original Content
The Facts
The core claim stems from Purbaya's public statements about the poor code quality in the Coretax system, likened to high school work by LG programmers, which is supported by multiple news sources from October 2025. However, the phrasing 'dikibuli' (deceived) adds sensationalism without evidence of intentional fraud, and the project cost is accurately reported as around Rp1.2-1.3 trillion. Partially true: factual basis but exaggerated for drama.
Benefit of the Doubt
The post advances a nationalist agenda criticizing foreign involvement in Indonesian government projects, using clickbait language to evoke outrage and boost engagement on social media. Key omissions include the government's proactive response, such as hiring local hackers for fixes and promises of completion by early 2026, which downplays positive developments. This selective framing shapes perception as a major scandal of deception, ignoring nuances like technical challenges in large-scale IT implementations and the consortium's selection process via PwC.
Visual Content Analysis
Images included in the original content
VISUAL DESCRIPTION
The image features a middle-aged Asian man in a white shirt and glasses, appearing concerned with his hand on his forehead, speaking into a microphone; overlaid with red circular icons showing 'X Error' symbols and brick-like red blocks suggesting system failure; a blue-tinted text box at the bottom repeats the headline in white text on a semi-transparent background; dark overall backdrop with the man positioned to the right.
TEXT IN IMAGE
MuslimVox Purbaya Ungkap: Indonesia Dikibuli Asing, Proyek Rp1,2 Triliun Coretax Diduga Hasil Kerja Level Lulusan SMA. @muslimvox
MANIPULATION
Composite graphic with added error icons and text overlays for dramatic effect; no signs of deepfake or photo alteration on the man's face, but the red error elements are digitally superimposed to symbolize IT failures.
TEMPORAL ACCURACY
The image aligns with events from October 2025, as Purbaya's statements were reported around October 24, 2025; no outdated clothing or event markers visible.
LOCATION ACCURACY
The man is depicted in a formal setting likely in Indonesia (e.g., press conference), consistent with Purbaya's role as Finance Minister; no geographical mismatches like foreign landmarks.
FACT-CHECK
The portrait matches public images of Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa from recent news photos; error overlays illustrate the Coretax issues but are interpretive, not literal evidence; reverse image search confirms similar photos from Indonesian media coverage of the minister's speeches in 2025.
How Is This Framed?
Biases, omissions, and misleading presentation techniques detected
Omits government responses like hiring local experts and project completion plans, presenting the issue as an unresolved scandal.
Problematic phrases:
"Indonesia Dikibuli Asing""Proyek Rp1,2 Triliun Coretax Diduga Hasil Kerja Level Lulusan SMA"What's actually there:
Ongoing fixes with local hackers and 2026 completion promise
What's implied:
Complete failure and deception without resolution
Impact: Leads readers to perceive total incompetence and betrayal, inflating outrage while downplaying proactive measures.
Implies intentional deception by foreigners without evidence, linking poor code quality directly to 'bullying' rather than technical challenges.
Problematic phrases:
"Dikibuli Asing"What's actually there:
Poor code quality reported but no proven intent to deceive
What's implied:
Deliberate fraud by foreign partners
Impact: Creates false narrative of malice, fostering distrust in international collaborations beyond the facts.
Uses 'Ungkap' (reveal) to suggest breaking, urgent scandal, despite the statement being from October 2025 reports.
Problematic phrases:
"Purbaya Ungkap"What's actually there:
What's implied:
Impact: Heightens emotional response and perceived immediacy, encouraging shares without verifying the non-urgent status.
Highlights the Rp1.2 trillion cost and high school-level work to exaggerate failure, ignoring partial successes or standard IT project risks.
Problematic phrases:
"Proyek Rp1,2 Triliun""Level Lulusan SMA"What's actually there:
Project cost accurate but includes standard implementation challenges
What's implied:
Total waste due to incompetence
Impact: Misleads on project magnitude as a catastrophic loss, amplifying financial scandal perception.
Sources & References
External sources consulted for this analysis
https://fajar.co.id/2025/10/24/coretax-habiskan-rp12-triliun-programmer-dari-lg-selevel-lulusan-sma-purbaya-komentarnya-lucu-deh-ri-sering-dikibuli-asing/
https://money.kompas.com/read/2025/10/24/155854026/programmer-coretax-dari-lg-tenyata-lulusan-sma-purbaya-ri-sering-dikibuli
https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/a/mengenal-3-perusahaan-asing-dalam-proyek-coretax-senilai-rp1-3-triliun-lt6789b53a48f69/
https://kolakaposnews.fajar.co.id/2025/10/25/menkeu-purbaya-blak-blakan-program-coretax-habiskan-rp12-triliun-dibuat-programmer-dari-lg-selevel-lulusan-sma/
https://www.cnnindonesia.com/ekonomi/20251024153533-532-1288138/purbaya-ungkap-programmer-coretax-dari-lg-sekelas-lulusan-sma
https://www.cnnindonesia.com/ekonomi/20251024153533-532-1288138/purbaya-ungkap-programmer-coretax-dari-lg-masih-lulusan-sma
https://video.kompas.com/watch/1877649/purbaya-janji-selesaikan-masalah-coretax-dalam-1-bulan
https://www.tribunnews.com/nasional/7746552/canda-purbaya-sebut-indonesia-sering-dikibulin-asing-usai-tahu-programmer-coretax-lulusan-sma
https://money.kompas.com/read/2025/10/24/155854026/programmer-coretax-dari-lg-tenyata-lulusan-sma-purbaya-ri-sering-dikibuli
https://www.cnnindonesia.com/ekonomi/20251024153533-532-1288138/purbaya-ungkap-programmer-coretax-dari-lg-sekelas-lulusan-sma
https://kolakaposnews.fajar.co.id/2025/10/25/menkeu-purbaya-blak-blakan-program-coretax-habiskan-rp12-triliun-dibuat-programmer-dari-lg-selevel-lulusan-sma/
https://finance.detik.com/berita-ekonomi-bisnis/d-8177910/purbaya-pakai-hacker-bereskan-coretax-orang-indonesia-bukan-asing
https://radartuban.jawapos.com/nasional/866747150/purbaya-akui-coretax-belum-rampung-dalam-sebulan-tapi-perbaikan-terus-meningkat
https://sumbarkita.id/menkeu-purbaya-ungkap-kualitas-kode-coretax-buruk-seperti-buatan-lulusan-sma/
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1848554703891919335
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1807598292072837506
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1865854209192780024
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1849052488852451779
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1882227050460913892
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1982279523719618636
https://www.cnnindonesia.com/ekonomi/20251024153533-532-1288138/purbaya-ungkap-programmer-coretax-dari-lg-sekelas-lulusan-sma
https://kolakaposnews.fajar.co.id/2025/10/25/menkeu-purbaya-blak-blakan-program-coretax-habiskan-rp12-triliun-dibuat-programmer-dari-lg-selevel-lulusan-sma/
https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20251024173026-4-679041/coretax-buatan-korea-bermasalah-purbaya-akan-putus-kontrak
https://fajar.co.id/2025/10/24/coretax-habiskan-rp12-triliun-programmer-dari-lg-selevel-lulusan-sma-purbaya-komentarnya-lucu-deh-ri-sering-dikibuli-asing/
https://en.tempo.co/read/2060105/coretax-repair-set-to-finish-in-january-2026-says-finance-minister-purbaya
https://www.viva.co.id/bisnis/1856838-menkeu-purbaya-rekrut-hacker-uji-keamanan-coretax-apa-hasilnya
https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23423INDONESIA_E_File_Final_VNR_2019_Indonesia.pdf
https://kolakaposnews.fajar.co.id/2025/10/25/menkeu-purbaya-blak-blakan-program-coretax-habiskan-rp12-triliun-dibuat-programmer-dari-lg-selevel-lulusan-sma/
https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20251024173026-4-679041/coretax-buatan-korea-bermasalah-purbaya-akan-putus-kontrak
https://joglosemarnews.com/2025/10/purbaya-targetkan-sistem-keuangan-ri-kebal-retas-coretax-jadi-model-keamanan-siber-nasional
https://liputan6.com/bisnis/read/6194127/purbaya-sindir-vendor-korea-di-proyek-coretax-hingga-senggol-k-pop-mungkin-kita-silau
https://cnnindonesia.com/ekonomi/20251024153533-532-1288138/purbaya-ungkap-programmer-coretax-dari-lg-masih-lulusan-sma
https://beritasatu.com/ekonomi/2934476/purbaya-soroti-coretax-kodenya-kayak-buatan-programer-lulusan-sma
https://kolakaposnews.fajar.co.id/2025/10/25/purbaya-rekrut-hacker-perkuat-tim-coretax-hacker-indonesia-jago-dan-ditakuti-dunia/
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1849052488852451779
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1810631671244308669
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1807598292072837506
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1848554703891919335
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1903557872501539310
https://x.com/jupliets/status/1980231782344921563
Want to see @jupliets's track record?
View their credibility score and all analyzed statements