Post by @CilliersB
56% credible (60% factual, 48% presentation). The post accurately reports Tshwane's 39% water losses and R777 million tanker expenditure under ANC-led administration, but the specific claim of only 2 pipe leaks and 23 faulty meters in Region 1 stems from a targeted campaign launch, not citywide data. The presentation suffers from omission framing and partisan bias, suggesting a cover-up without sufficient evidence.
Analysis Summary
The post highlights a discrepancy between citywide 39% water losses and the ANC-led administration's claim of only 2 pipe leaks and 23 faulty meters in Region 1, suggesting incompetence or cover-up amid R777 million water tanker spending. The claim aligns with reported high water losses and overspending on tankers, though the administration's specific figures appear from an official campaign launch emphasizing targeted interventions. Counter-arguments from the city focus on proactive leak detection efforts, but omit broader systemic issues like infrastructure decay.
Original Content
The Facts
The post's core claims are supported by recent reports of 39% water losses and R777 million tanker expenditure under the ANC-led coalition, contrasting with the city's optimistic campaign figures; however, the accusation of hiding truth is interpretive. Mostly accurate with partisan framing.
Benefit of the Doubt
The author advances a pro-DA agenda by criticizing ANC governance failures in water management, portraying the administration as negligent or corrupt to rally opposition support. Key omissions include the city's context of launching a targeted ThibaLeaks campaign to address leaks, potentially downplaying ongoing efforts amid acknowledged infrastructure challenges. This selective emphasis on discrepancies shapes perception of total incompetence, ignoring nuances like regional variations and budget constraints.
Visual Content Analysis
Images included in the original content
VISUAL DESCRIPTION
The image is a scanned or photographed official media statement document from the City of Tshwane, featuring the city logo at the top, dated 20 October 2025, with highlighted sections in red emphasizing results in Region 1 such as cleared sewer blockages, assessed water meters, and fixed pipe leaks as part of the ThibaLeaks Campaign launch.
TEXT IN IMAGE
MEDIA STATEMENT ThibaLeaks Campaign launched to prevent water losses in Region 1 20 October 2025 The City of Tshwane has stepped up its efforts to combat water losses with the official launch of the ThibaLeaks Campaign in Region 1. This ThibaLeaks Campaign is a significant milestone in the city's ongoing drive to improve water conservation. The ThibaLeaks Campaign is a proactive and service delivery orientated initiative aimed at identifying, repairing and preventing illegal connections that result in high non-revenue water losses. This initiative forms part of the Water Services Priority Action Plan, under the pillar of Infrastructure Development and Service Reliability. As part of the campaign, rapid deployment of skilled technical teams to pressure test all sewers and water meter illegal and burst pipes, removal of sewer blockages and meter verification and awareness. In Region 1, the campaign has already yielded impressive results. Of the 415 sewer blockages identified, 359 have been cleared, with a balance of 56 targeted for clearance in the next week. For water meters, 415 were assessed, achieving the resolution of one illegal connection, while 18 of 50 pipe leaks were scoped, successfully fixed. On the sanitation progress, sewer blockages have been cleared, with the balance improved. The campaign underscores the city's unwavering commitment to protect its water resources and reduce avoidable losses. Every litre saved through ThibaLeaks contributes directly to the sustainability, helping secure a reliable and efficient water supply system for the residents of Tshwane today and for generations to come. Issued by the Communication, Marketing and Events Department. [Additional footer text in various languages and contact details]
MANIPULATION
No signs of editing, inconsistencies, or artifacts; appears to be an authentic official document with standard formatting, logos, and multilingual footers typical of municipal releases.
TEMPORAL ACCURACY
Document dated 20 October 2025, aligning with the current date of 21 October 2025, and references recent campaign launch, making it timely to the post's context.
LOCATION ACCURACY
The document explicitly pertains to Region 1 in the City of Tshwane, matching the post's reference to local water issues in that area.
FACT-CHECK
The image accurately depicts an official City of Tshwane media statement announcing the ThibaLeaks Campaign, with verifiable claims of interventions in Region 1 (e.g., 359/415 sewer blockages cleared, 18/50 pipe leaks fixed); cross-referenced with news sources confirming the campaign's existence and focus on leak prevention, though citywide losses remain high per independent reports.
How Is This Framed?
Biases, omissions, and misleading presentation techniques detected
Omits the context of the administration's ThibaLeaks campaign launch, which provides targeted leak detection efforts, leading readers to view the low Region 1 figures as total denial rather than regional focus.
Problematic phrases:
"Yet the ANC-led administration claims Region 1 only has 2 pipe leaks and 23 faulty meters"What's actually there:
Figures from official campaign emphasizing interventions in Region 1 amid acknowledged citywide issues
What's implied:
Administration ignoring or denying broader water losses
Impact: Readers perceive the administration as wholly incompetent or deceptive, overlooking proactive measures and regional variations in infrastructure challenges.
Fails to mention counter-evidence like budget constraints and ongoing infrastructure decay acknowledged by the city, presenting the discrepancy as pure negligence.
Problematic phrases:
"Either they have no clue what’s happening in Tshwane, or they’re hiding the truth"What's actually there:
City reports proactive efforts and systemic challenges like decay
What's implied:
No efforts or awareness of issues
Impact: Amplifies perception of corruption or ignorance, suppressing balanced view of multifaceted water management problems.
Implies the low leak numbers are a cover for justifying the tanker spending without evidence of direct causation or motive.
Problematic phrases:
"hiding the truth behind a R777 million tanker splurge"What's actually there:
Spending reported as response to losses, not proven cover-up
What's implied:
Spending directly tied to hiding leaks
Impact: Leads readers to infer corrupt intent, creating unfounded causal link between regional stats and citywide spending.
Contrasts citywide 39% losses with Region 1 specifics without noting regional differences, misleading on overall scale of issues.
Problematic phrases:
"Citywide, water losses sit at 39%. Yet... Region 1 only has 2 pipe leaks"What's actually there:
Losses vary by region; Region 1 focus is targeted
What's implied:
Low Region 1 numbers represent citywide reality
Impact: Exaggerates discrepancy to suggest uniform underreporting, distorting perception of problem magnitude across the city.
Sources & References
External sources consulted for this analysis
https://www.news24.com/investigations/tanking-finances-tshwanes-water-tanker-spend-spirals-to-r777m-under-anc-led-coalition-20251018-1068
https://dagauteng.org.za/2025/10/da-launches-investigation-into-r777-million-tshwane-water-tanker-jackpot
https://centralnews.co.za/tshwane-eff-mmc-obakeng-responds-to-r777-million-water-tanker-overspend-awaits-full-finance-report-amid-da-probe/
https://www.biznews.com/leadership/da-launches-investigation-tshwane-water-tankers
https://www.citizen.co.za/news/tshwanes-r777m-water-tanker-scandal-sparks-fury/
https://www.citizen.co.za/news/tshwane-further-water-restrictions/
https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2025-10-20-da-wants-answers-about-tshwanes-r700m-water-tanker-bill/
https://www.citizen.co.za/news/tshwanes-r777m-water-tanker-scandal-sparks-fury/
https://www.biznews.com/leadership/da-launches-investigation-tshwane-water-tankers
https://www.news24.com/investigations/tanking-finances-tshwanes-water-tanker-spend-spirals-to-r777m-under-anc-led-coalition-20251018-1068
https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2025-10-20-da-wants-answers-about-tshwanes-r700m-water-tanker-bill/
https://centralnews.co.za/tshwane-eff-mmc-obakeng-responds-to-r777-million-water-tanker-overspend-awaits-full-finance-report-amid-da-probe/
https://pretorianews.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-10-09-broken-pipes-and-dry-taps-tshwane-residents-fight-for-water-infrastructure-renewal/
https://ewn.co.za/2025/10/21/soil-of-sa-urges-tshwane-to-invest-money-in-permanent-water-infrastructure-instead-of-tankers
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1977026337597444248
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1908743549278879830
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1855292126134948166
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1910304730175136044
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1889317523859890476
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1895038075429953904
https://www.biznews.com/leadership/da-launches-investigation-tshwane-water-tankers
https://centralnews.co.za/tshwane-eff-mmc-obakeng-responds-to-r777-million-water-tanker-overspend-awaits-full-finance-report-amid-da-probe/
https://www.news24.com/investigations/tanking-finances-tshwanes-water-tanker-spend-spirals-to-r777m-under-anc-led-coalition-20251018-1068
https://dagauteng.org.za/2025/10/da-launches-investigation-into-r777-million-tshwane-water-tanker-jackpot
https://www.citizen.co.za/news/tshwanes-r777m-water-tanker-scandal-sparks-fury/
https://www.e-tshwane.co.za/eTshwane/
https://udm.org.za/post/exposing-the-water-tanker-mafia-udm-urges-scopa-to-act-on-corruption-and-sabotage-in-municipal-supply
https://www.citizen.co.za/news/tshwanes-r777m-water-tanker-scandal-sparks-fury/
https://www.biznews.com/leadership/da-launches-investigation-tshwane-water-tankers
https://centralnews.co.za/tshwane-eff-mmc-obakeng-responds-to-r777-million-water-tanker-overspend-awaits-full-finance-report-amid-da-probe/
https://ewn.co.za/2025/10/21/soil-of-sa-urges-tshwane-to-invest-money-in-permanent-water-infrastructure-instead-of-tankers
https://www.news24.com/investigations/tanking-finances-tshwanes-water-tanker-spend-spirals-to-r777m-under-anc-led-coalition-20251018-1068
https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2025-10-20-da-wants-answers-about-tshwanes-r700m-water-tanker-bill/
https://iol.co.za/news/2025-09-08-city-of-tshwane-faces-r1-3-billion-water-losses-amid-infrastructure-challenges
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1977026337597444248
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1908743549278879830
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1889317523859890476
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1855292126134948166
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1910304730175136044
https://x.com/CilliersB/status/1895038075429953904
Want to see @CilliersB's track record?
View their credibility score and all analyzed statements